Evil, I

Stephen McLaughlin

Executive Producer

Alena Acker

June Cicero

Mike Funk

Mustached Cop

Brian Ish

Investigator

Martha Morgan

Lead Detective

Allie Nelson

Patty Ives

Matthew F. O'Connor

Arthur Shawcross

Rodney Roldan

Police Officer

Anne-Marie Agbodji

Sandra

Michael Santosusso

Detective

Justin Morck

Witness

Jonah Young

Larry Bittaker

Mikaal Bates

Voice of Killer

Elan Even

Officer John

Matthew L. Imparato

Voice of Killer

Christopher Mele

Gary Smith

Joshua Schubart

Detective Collins

Mark Carapezza

Voice of Killer

Risa Cohen

Adrienne Cullen

Isaac J. Cruz

Voice of Killer

Nicholas Dullea

Principal / Supporting

James Rose

E.M.T.

Omar Torres

Erne Ballinger / Lieutenant

Kae Cohen

Voice of Killer

Kenric Green

Nathaniel White

Sherita Rankins

Friend of Angelina and Brenda

Shawn Curran

Frank Hilley

Joseph J. DiMartino

Detective

Rachel Kaplove

Carol Hilley

Nicolás Martínez

Voice of the Killer and Actress

Graham Powell

Mike Hilley

Tim Rerucha

Arresting Detective

Elise Sievert

Bonnie Ferris

Robert Wilde

Voice of the Killer

J.D. Brown

Detective Fallin

Jake

Martin

Silvana Jakich

Mrs. Houghteling

Lauren A. Kennedy

Laura Houghteling

Matthew McCurdy

Hadden Clark

DeLance Minefee

Officer Edwards

Sandra Palmeri

Mrs. Ruthersburg

David Donahoe

Detective Hodgeman

Chelsea Gonzalez

Michelle Maday

Rob Morgan

Voice of the Killer

Yanelba Roldan

Melinda Aguilar

Jessica Renee Russell

Rebecca Huff

Alissa Salvatore

Helen Dutcher

Charles F. Wagner IV

Detective Paul Bunton

Tom Waters

Jeff (The Neighbor)

Steve Mason

Officer

Steve Ward

Voice of Killer