The Easiest Problem Everyone Gets Wrong

We know how difficult the Monty Hall Problem is for so many people even after they’re shown all the math behind the best possible strategy. It’s basic probability, but it’s deceptive -- and it all started with the Bertrand’s Box Paradox.

In this video, I go back to the origins of a probability problem that continues to plague humanity. And it all started in 1889 when French mathematician Joseph Bertrand published his “Calcul des probabilités,” which included a simple scenario involving gold and silver coins.

70 years later, recreational math columnist Martin Gardner unveiled The Three Prisoners Problem involving the pardoning of one of three prisoners scheduled to be executed. The mathematical concept was the same as Bertrand’s Box, but The Three Prisoners continued to be a probability paradox that haunted everyone from the readers of Scientific American to professional mathematicians.

But the Monty Hall Problem is really what made this mathematical illusion explode. By the 1990s, there was an all-out argument about whether all of these problems -- Bertrand’s Box, Three Prisoners, and Monty Hall -- were paradoxes or simple 50/50 coin flips. It’s time to go back to the beginning… and show why there’s something even more important than solving this math problem.

*** SOURCES ***

Krauss and Wang, “The Psychology of the Monty Hall Problem: Discovering Psychological Mechanisms for Solving a Tenacious Brain Teaser”: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/10839512_The_Psychology_of_the_Monty_Hall_Problem_Discovering_Psychological_Mechanisms_for_Solving_a_Tenacious_Brain_Teaser

“Why Humans Fail in Solving the Monty Hall Dilemma: A Systematic Review”: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6194549/

Joseph Bertrand’s “Calcul des Probabilités”: https://archive.org/download/calculdesprobab00bertgoog/calculdesprobab00bertgoog.pdf

Dan MacKinnon (mathrecreation), “Monty Hall and The Three Prisoners”: http://www.mathrecreation.com/2009/03/monty-hall-and-three-prisoners.html

Dan Jacob Wallace, “Bertrand’s Box Paradox (With and Without Bayes’ Theorem): https://www.untrammeledmind.com/2018/11/bertrands-box-paradox/

Eugene P. Northrop, “Riddles in Mathematics”: https://archive.org/details/RiddlesInMathematics/page/n167/mode/2up

*** LINKS ***

Special thanks to Internet Historian: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCR1D15p_vdP3HkrH8wgjQRw

Vsauce2:
Twitter: https://twitter.com/VsauceTwo
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/VsauceTwo
Talk Vsauce2 in the TCU Discord: https://discord.gg/tyh7AVm

Hosted and Produced by Kevin Lieber
Instagram: http://instagram.com/kevlieber
Twitter: https://twitter.com/kevinlieber
Podcast: https://www.youtube.com/thecreateunknown

Research And Writing by Matthew Tabor
https://twitter.com/TaborTCU

Editing by John Swan
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJuSltoYKrAUKnbYO5EMZ2A

Huge Thanks To Paula Lieber
https://www.etsy.com/shop/Craftality

Select Music By Jake Chudnow: http://www.youtube.com/user/JakeChudnow

Get Vsauce's favorite science and math toys delivered to your door!
https://www.curiositybox.com/

#education #vsauce2 #learning

BetaSeries' opinion

Rediscover the Hilarious World of '=3': A Must-Watch YouTube Sensation

In the vast universe of online entertainment, few shows have made as much impact as "=3". Hosted initially by the charismatic Ray William Johnson, this YouTube web series quickly became a staple for comedy lovers around the globe. With its unique format that combined viral video commentary with sharp wit, "=3" captured the hearts of millions. As it evolved through various hosts like Robby Motz and Kaja Martin, its legacy continued to influence internet culture in profound ways.

The show's inception can be traced back to a time when YouTube was burgeoning with creativity and innovation. Ray William Johnson's dynamic presence and clever humor created an unmatched viewing experience that resonated with audiences seeking laughter and entertainment. His ability to dissect viral videos with humorous insights made "=3" not just a show but a weekly ritual for many fans.

After Ray stepped down in March 2014, Robby Motz took over hosting duties, bringing his own flair while maintaining the essence of what made "=3" so beloved. Although some viewers were skeptical at first, Robby's charm eventually won them over, keeping the fan base engaged and entertained. However, transitions are never easy in long-running shows; when Kaja Martin became the host in July 2015, she faced challenges in retaining viewership amidst changing internet trends.

Read the full article

Next episode

S01E364 - Can Learning Make You Dumb? Yes.