Happy Face

Annaleigh Ashford

Melissa Reed

Dennis Quaid

Keith Jesperson aka 'Happy Face Killer'

James Wolk

Ben Reed

Tamera Tomakili

Ivy Campbell

Khiyla Aynne

Hazel Reed

Benjamin Mackey

Max Reed

Connor Paton

Tyler

David Harewood

Dr. Greg

Momona Tamada

Eva

Michael O'Neill

D.A. Craig Calloway

River Codack

Josh

Zara Nikou Sichani

Victoria

Damon Gupton

Elijah

Charles Zuckermann

C.O. Bassett

Marci T. House

Joyce

Beverley Elliott

Denise's Friend

Nola Augustson

Denise

Ava Telek

Summer

Philip Granger

Chave

Kathleen Duborg

June

Jennifer Spence

Renee

Kate Sullivan

Teen Melissa

Kiefer O'Reilly

Teen Shane

Zabryna Guevara

Gabriela

Patrick Gilmore

Cody O'Neill

Eric Keenleyside

Carl O'Neill

Teach Grant

Ashton McBride

Jason Beaudoin

Frankie

Jenn Lyon

Gillian

Harrison Xu

Stewart

Cammie Clarke

Young Becky

Chanelle Peloso

Adele

Ramona Kim

Mrs. Walters / Ms. Walters

Shayn Walker

Texas Prison Guard #1

Debbie Podowski

Jackie

Philip Ettinger

Shane

Paul McGillion

William

Toby Hargrave

Bob

Jonathan Whitesell

Nico

Sandy Sidhu

Dr. Wendy Chin

Hilary McCormack

Heather

Lisa Solberg

Reporter #1

Christopher Pearce

Reporter #2

Jenna Romanin

Tabitha

Jillian Fargey

Kathy Weaver

Gregory Greenwood

Joseph

Melissa G. Moore

Segment Producer

Carson Bokenfohr

Clerk

Fabian Gujral

John the Lawyer

Doris Maria Bregolisse

Reporter

Richard Elias Anderson

Mail Carrier

Rina Pellerin

Female Bartender

Vale Cooper

Young Missy

Johnny Scozzafava

Young Shane

Paul Moniz de Sa

Gary

Derek Kwan

Spokane Officer #1

Ben Christensen

Spokane Officer #2

Leah Jacksties

Extra Heather

Maria Ameerali

Owner

Rebecca Husain

Tina

Arvin Shah

General Store Clerk

Lola Rose Mackay

Bully Girl #1

Kristina Lao

Roxanne

Elizabeth Weinstein

Lydia Morgan

Ted Cole

Eddie

Amanda May

Caryn

Jasmine Lukuku

Frances

Eugene Mundowa

Rodrigo

Liz Wallace

Hannah

Mark Kandborg

Harrold Griffin

Gardiner Millar

Pastor Baker

Cecil MacRae

Young Ash

Ali Tarhouni

Chef Emilio

Tim Dixon

Judge

Darryl Scheelar

Prosecutor

Tyson Bellusci

Solitary Guard

Kyle Rideout

Brendan

Belinda Williams

Aunt Claire

Lynnette Kissoon

Receptionist

Billy Wickman

Manny

Kapila Rego

Lark

Aaron Paul Stewart

Thrift Store Employee

Brandon McEwan

Teen Brendan

Elias Leacock

Young Elijah

Wonser De-Gbon

Flo Carter

Jennie George

Diane

Patricia Drake

Alice

Patsy Thompson

Nico's Mother

Nevin Burkholder

New Store Clerk

Anthony Bailey

Texan Prison Guard #2

James Coupland

Texas Prison Guard #3

Sharmaine Yeoh

DNA Lab Tech

John Tench

Ziggy

Sandy Robson

Ennis / Driver

Stephanie Cho

Junior Associate

Jorden Birch

Bailiff

Michael St. John Smith

Judge Wilkins

Micah Steinke

OSP Guard

Otto Szabo

Black-Eyed Inmate

Ziah Diango

Little Girl

Jamall Johnson

Inmate #1

Melissah Charboneau

Bartender

Lisbeth Rosana

Female Bar Patron

Jordan Dannish

Lawyer (uncredited)

Peter Cambor

Young Carl O'Neill

Nathan Parrott

Teen Keith

Stew McLean

Les (Keith's Father)

Emmet Matheson

Smitty

Trey Helten

Prisoner #1

Karen Khunkhun

Reporter

Gavin Langelo

OSP Prison Guard

Emmanuel Amadeo Badal

Basketball Prisoner

Shaw Madson

Sheriff Deputy

Brittany Clough

Bartender