Brotherly Love

Joey Lawrence

Joe Roman

Matthew Lawrence

Matt Roman

Andrew Lawrence

Andy Roman

Michael McShane

Lloyd Burwell

Liz Vassey

Louise Davis

Melinda Culea

Claire Roman

Rebecca Herbst

Kristin

Jonathan C. Kaplan

Ira Stoltzer

Sid Melton

Captain Speedy / Delivery Man / Messenger

Karl David-Djerf

Silent Jim

Michael Lowry

Josh

Tom Kenny

Doug / Lucien

Adam Consolo

Lance

Suzanne Kent

Sheila

Lauren Woodland

Julia

Chuck E. Weiss

Leo

Dana Kaminski

Comic Con Patron / Pastor Selover

Terri Conn

Girl

Sarah Silverman

Rosa

Wendy Benson-Landes

Bridget

George Takei

George Takei

Peter Krause

Tom

Nell Carter

Nell Bascombe

Gil Gerard

Big Mike

Tyler Layton

Debbie

Rip Taylor

Rip Taylor / Hank

Keene Curtis

Mr. Hangarter

Jodie Sweetin

Lydia Lump

Elisabeth Harnois

Carly

Blake Clark

Mickey

Victor Raider-Wexler

Mr. Levenstein

Tricia Leigh Fisher

Miss Harper

Shiri Appleby

Fairy #1

Estelle Getty

Myrna Burwell

Gina Gallego

Lupe

Jennifer Aspen

Melanie

Mike Starr

Gus

Tom Arnold

Jack

Portia Dawson

Suzie

Nestor Carbonell

Eduardo

Lee Arenberg

Herb Pasternack

Lisa Rieffel

Amy

Jennifer Lyons

Patty

Billy West

Billy

Andrea Bendewald

Phoebe

Bryan Cranston

Russell

Stephen Lee

Cop

Terry Bradshaw

Terry Bradshaw

Melody Kay

Robin

Justine Johnston

Mrs. Maguire

Shana Smith

Fairy #2

Dustin Voigt

Oberon

Mathea Webb

Christy

Ann Marie Lee

Mrs. Ford

Joel Jordan

Johnny Romano

Melissa Clayton

Andrea

Chuck Bailey

Limo Driver

Hiram Kasten

Tour Guide

Laura Summer

Julie

Brant von Hoffman

Missing Sock

Melanie Hutsell

Wilma

John Kassir

Cryptkeeper

Derk Cheetwood

College Kid

Tommy Bertelsen

Tin Woodsman

Megan Cavanagh

Lotus

Tessa Grobel

Nancy

Lisa Anne Morrison

Helga

Joey Herman

Bill Fody

Randy Herman

Buck Fody

David Byrd

Alfred

J.R. Ross

Jeff

Jeremy Linson

Dave

Vincent Guastaferro

Dominick Benito

Rodney Kageyama

Mr. Woo

Marius Mazmanian

Old Man

Daniella Garcia

Marissa

Jimmy Briscoe

Jimmy

Myra Turley

Annica

Raci Alexander

Coco

Marc Weiner

Marc Weiner

Veena Bidasha

Ava

Neena Bidasha

Eva

Linden Chiles

Chuck

Blaire Baron

Millie

Aron Eisenberg

Little Ricky

Tony Carreiro

Jimmy

Eddie Gorodetsky

Butcher

F.J. O'Neil

Mr. Willis

Luigi Amodeo

Eduardo

Ara Maxwell

Gwen

Christine Wilson

Sue

Phil Proctor

Art Dealer

Mike Grief

Tattoo Guy

Ivory Ocean

Lenny

André Carthen

Lucien

Al Ruscio

Harry Gibbs

Jonathan Schmock

Chip

T.E. Russell

Damon

Holly Gagnier

Fiona

Tara Boger

Jeneane

Michael Keenan

Announcer

Kevin Meaney

Ken

Jane Fleiss

Amber

Camille Winbush

Emma Aimes (uncredited)