I Met My Murderer Online

David Sheinkopf

Narrator (voice)

Eldridge Armstrong

Self - Secret Service Agent

Patricia 'Patches' Brown

Self - Influencer / Self - True Crime Expert

Sara Azari

Self - Criminal Defense Attorney

Joe Garner

Self - Best-Selling Author & Journalist

Tom Ohmer

Self - Retired Police Officer

Dr. Judy Ho

Self - Clinical Psychologist

Alison Triessl

Self - Criminal Defense Attorney

Monaye Moyes

Grace Millane

Anirudh Pisharody

Fahim Saleh

Christopher McClellan

Tyrese Haspil

A.K. Uppal

The Cousin

David Klein

Self - Tech Expert / Influencer

Christina Ricucci

Sydney Loofe

Leanna Huffman

Bailey Boswell

Michael Paul King

Aubrey Trail

James 'Chilli' Chillingworth

Detective Robert Hurley

John David Gregory

Detective Mike Maseth

John J. Pistone

Detective Eli McBride

Tom A. McDonald

Detective Corey Townsend

Sarah Cooper

Witch #1

Jordan Van Clief

Witch #2

Julia Coulter

Witch #3

Alyssa Alexander

Brooklyn McCrystal

Megan Bourgeois

Brittney Flynn

Roy Allen

Alan Koll

Robin S. Roth

Jennifer Koll

Jon Lee Richardson

Dayton Koll

Debra Tiesi

The Coin Lady

Sho Omada

Antique Store Owner #1

Christian Marcus

Antique Store Owner #2

Mike Kiely

Jesse Kempson

Eliezer Ortiz

Detective Inspector

Brookelynn Elizabeth

Blonde Date

Christine Kim

Brunette Date

Pop Smoke

Self (archive footage)

Clayton McInerney

Cody

Jackie Green

Tim

Alfie Robinson

Uber Driver