@midnight

Chris Hardwick

Self - Host

Willam Belli

Himself - Winner

Jenny Nicholson

Herself

Hal Rudnick

Himself

Andy Signore

Himself

Kumail Nanjiani

Self

Natasha Leggero

Self

Kurt Braunohler

Self

Brendon Walsh

Self

June Diane Raphael

Self

James Adomian

Self

Mike Lawrence

Self

Kyle Kinane

Self

Deon Cole

Self

Eugene Mirman

Self

Kristen Schaal

Self

Matt Braunger

Self

Nikki Glaser

Self

Patton Oswalt

Self

Matt Besser

Self

Megan Neuringer

Self

Scott Aukerman

Self

Moshe Kasher

Self

Steve Agee

Self

Jonah Ray Rodrigues

Self

Thomas Lennon

Self / Self - Guest

Ali Wong

Self

Howard Kremer

Self

Rhys Darby

Self

Michael Che

Self

Iliza Shlesinger

Self

Randy Sklar

Self

Jason Sklar

Self

Ron Funches

Self

Baron Vaughn

Self

Julie Klausner

Self

Paul F. Tompkins

Self

John Hodgman

Self

Grace Helbig

Self

Judd Apatow

Self

David Koechner

Self

Andi Osho

Self

Neal Brennan

Self

David Spade

Self

Paul Scheer

Self

Rich Eisen

Self

Adam Savage

Self

Andrea Savage

Self

Nick Offerman

Self

Norman Reedus

Self

Ike Barinholtz

Self

Andy Daly

Forrest MacNeil / Self

Jenny Slate

Self

Cristela Alonzo

Self

Doug Benson

Self / Weed Correspondent

Rory Scovel

Self

Jon Dore

Self

Beth Stelling

Self

Jen Kirkman

Self

Kevin Bacon

Self

Arden Myrin

Self

Al Madrigal

Self

'Weird Al' Yankovic

Self

Brian Posehn

Self

Annie Lederman

Self

Julian McCullough

Self

Jon Daly

Self

Horatio Sanz

Self

Adam Scott

Self

Michael Showalter

Self

Kerri Kenney

Self

Michael Ian Black

Self

Robert Ben Garant

Self - Guest

Michael Patrick Jann

Self - Guest

Ken Marino

Self - Guest

Joe Lo Truglio

Self - Guest

David Wain

Self - Guest

Myq Kaplan

Self

Jamie Lee

Self

Riki Lindhome

Self

Kyle Dunnigan

Self

Brody Stevens

Self

Seth Herzog

Self

Tony Hale

Self - Guest

Nick Thune

Self

Dana Gould

Self

Sean Patton

Self

Michelle Buteau

Self

St. Vincent

Self - Guest

Neko Case

Self

Joe Manganiello

Self - Guest

Abbi Jacobson

Self

Ilana Glazer

Self

Hannibal Buress

Self

Nate Bargatze

Self

Dan Soder

Self

Aparna Nancherla

Self

Brett Gelman

Self

Matt Walsh

Self

Ian Roberts

Self

Jimmy Pardo

Self

James Davis

Self

Kit Harington

Self - Guest

Tommy Johnagin

Self

Rob Delaney

Self

Danny Pudi

Self

Gillian Jacobs

Self

Jim Rash

Self

Neil deGrasse Tyson

Self - Guest

Rob Corddry

Self

Hannah Hart

Self

Mamrie Hart

Self

Christopher Irvine

Self

Andy Kindler

Self

Maria Bamford

Self

Rob Huebel

Self

Michaela Watkins

Self

Kevin Smith

Self

Jason Mewes

Self

Ralph Garman

Self

Dominic Monaghan

Self

Kulap Vilaysack

Self

Wil Wheaton

Self

Matt Mira

Self

Walton Goggins

Self - Guest

W. Kamau Bell

Self

Eliza M. Skinner

Self

Todd Barry

Self

Jenny Johnson

Self

Dan Levy

Self

Ben Kronberg

Self

Greg Proops

Self

Seth Green

Self

Rachel Bloom

Self

Kevin Shinick

Self

Sean O'Connor

Self - Contestant

Nick Swardson

Self

Dave Hill

Self

James Davis

Self

Guy Branum

Self - Panelist

Jesse Joyce

Self / The @midnight bully

Paget Brewster

Self

Sarah Tiana

Self

Roy Wood Jr.

Self

Colleen Smith

Star Schlessinger (voice)

Victor Yerrid

Hot Dog (voice)

Bryan Callen

Self

Esther Povitsky

Self

Chris Fairbanks

Self

Randy Liedtke

Self

April Richardson

Self

Rick Glassman

Self

Erinn Hayes

Self

Alison Rich

Self

Flula Borg

Self

Ryan Stout

Self

Brandon Wardell

Self

Scott Adsit

Self

Annabeth Gish

Self

Adam Cayton-Holland

Self

Robert Smigel

Triumph the Insult Comic Dog (voice)

Heather Anne Campbell

Self

Jeff Bryan Davis

Self

Dan Harmon

Self

Emily Fleming

Self

Chelsey Crisp

Self

Randall Park

Self

Maria Thayer

Self

Affion Crockett

Self

Tiffany Haddish

Self

Jamar Malachi Neighbors

Self

Will Ferrell

President George W. Bush / Self - Guest

Cameron Esposito

Self

Lamorne Morris

Self

Carrot Top

Self

Lucia Aniello

Self

Paul W. Downs

Self

Tyler Labine

Self

Adam Conover

Self

Alice Wetterlund

Self

Christopher Masterson

Self

Alanna Masterson

Self

Danny Masterson

Self

Anthony Atamanuik

Self

Jimmy Carr

Self

Sara Schaefer

Self

Reid Scott

Self

Timothy Simons

Self

Jen D'Angelo

Self

Chris Gethard

Self

Erica Rhodes

Self

Aisha Tyler

Self

Rachael Harris

Self

Damien Lemon

Self

Craig Ferguson

Self

Ginger Gonzaga

Self

Jessica Lowe

Self

Robert Kirkman

Self

Steve Warky Nunez

Self - Audience Member

Jim Florentine

Self

Bonnie McFarlane

Self

Jim Norton

Self

Mary Lynn Rajskub

Self

Rob Kellum

Stro

Matteo Lane

Self

Jay Oakerson

Self

Mary Holland

Self

Spike Feresten

Self

Eli Roth

Self

Burnie Burns

Self

Barbara Dunkelman

Self

Gavin Free

Self

Mike Phirman

Self

Chelsea Davison

Janet Rose Solenne / Self

Robin Thede

Self

Brendon Small

Self

Louie Anderson

Self

Martha Kelly

Self

Bob Saget

Self

Alex Edelman

Self

Danielle Panabaker

Self

Bobby Lee

Self

Yassir Lester

Self

Russell Peters

Self

Betsy Sodaro

Self

Ross Marquand

Self - Guest appearance

Matthew Broussard

Self

Kate Micucci

Self

Yakov Smirnoff

Self

Brent Weinbach

Self

Brandon Johnson

Self

Colton Dunn

Self

Lauren Lapkus

Self

Jordan Morris

Self

Nate Mooney

Self

Janet Varney

Self

Jena Friedman

Self

Brian Huskey

Self

Jim Jefferies

Self

Johnathan Fernandez

Self

Jordan Rock

Self

Whitney Cummings

Self - Panelist

Dolph Lundgren

Self - Guest Appearance

Vladimir Caamaño

Self

Chris D'Elia

Self

Samm Levine

Self

Dan Levy

Self

Arielle Vandenberg

Self

Bridget Everett

Self

John Ross Bowie

Self

J. Mandyam

Self

Dana Carvey

Self

Janeane Garofalo

Self

Matt Goldich

Self

Noel Fielding

Self

Rich Fulcher

Self

J. Mascis

Self

Janelle James

Self

Sam Morril

Self

Jon Gabrus

Self

Michael Chiklis

Self - Guest appearance

Nate Fernald

Self

Morgan Murphy

Self

Reggie Watts

Self

Fortune Feimster

Self

Milana Vayntrub

Self

Diona Reasonover

Self

Andy Richter

Self

Laurie Kilmartin

Self

Amanda Seales

Self

Dave Allen

Father Mike / Krampus

Dan Bakkedahl

Self

Betsy Brandt

Self

Thomas Sadoski

Self

Katie O'Brien

Self

Matt Kirshen

Self

Josie Long

Self

Megan Gailey

Self

Jak Knight

Self

Judah Friedlander

Self

Erin Gibson

Self

Bryan Safi

Self

Dave Anthony

Self

Stephanie Simbari

Self