The Witch of East Chatswin

Jane Levy

Tessa Altman

Jeremy Sisto

George Altman

Carly Chaikin

Dalia Royce

Allie Grant

Lisa Shay

Cheryl Hines

Dallas Royce

Alan Tudyk

Noah Werner

Rex Lee

Mr. Wolfe

Ana Gasteyer

Sheila Shay

Chris Parnell

Fred Shay

Evan Arnold

Chef Alan

Katelyn Pacitto

Kaitlin

Kara Pacitto

Kenzie

Maestro Harrell

Malik

Parker Young

Ryan Shay

Abbie Cobb

Kimantha

Natalija Nogulich

Marcheeza

Rachel Dratch

Paula Weingelb

William Marquart

Bartender

Tiffany Martin

Young Paula

Frances Mary McKittrick

Young Sheila

Mike Dazé

Valet