Your Worst Nightmare

D.C. Goode

Narrator (voice)

Jason Shablik

Narrator (voice)

Samuel Goergen

Logan

Christie McNab

Heather Kelso

Rolando Madigral

Gerry DeJesus

Michael Hanson

Matt Kelso

Jimmy Dempster

Hank

Nicole Lamb

Briana Helwick

Andrés Erickson

Avery

Kate Dailey

Kimberly Cook

Kenny Guerra

Justin Helwick

Rultz Raymond

Detective Swayze's Partner

JoAnn Willette

Debbie Puglisi

Hope Jordan

Carrie Cauldill

Nicole Paris Williams

Barbara Nunn

Kamille McCuin

Cherry Lee Jones

Marlon Perrier

Nelson Jones

Skyler Adams

Jimmy Mickel

Eli T. Peña

Chip Hojan

Euseph Messiah

Sam Hobson

Taina Dominguez

Marie Mendez

Autumn Dial

Tammie Craycraft

Kyle Findley

Cody Simmons

Langley Cornwell

Connie Craycraft

Jack Andrews

Christopher Burns

Megan Rosen

Christy Williams

Julia Vasi

Jodi Sanderholm

Courtney Dietz

Lori Virden

Vanessa French

Cindy Sanderholm

Jack Vincenty

Owen

Burke Brown

Justin Thurber

Mark Knapp

Jake

Aly Ward Azevedo

Anna Wood

Ciarra Siller

Marie Wood

Pamela Gold

Jeanne Smith

David Christian Welborn

Mike Iseman

Travis West

Ron

Braxton Bjerken

Nick Robinson

Jeremy T. Thomas

Scott Wells

Joe Morelli

Detective Bob Anton

Nir Guzinski

Bar Patron

Todd Sheeler

Detective Gerald Swayze

Margaret Press

Self - Author, "A Scream on the Water"

Sarafina King

Martha Brailsford / Muriel (twin sister)

Jason MacDonald

Tom Maimoni

Dorian Santiago

Det. Sgt. Conrad Prosniewski

Lindsay Abernathy

Rosemary

Ashlee Heath

Patti Maimoni

Levi Burdick

Brian Brailsford

Jesse Malinowski

Hooper Goodwin

Casie Bryant

Maggie (Neighbor)

Marty Stonerock

Laurie Cabot (Salem Psychic)

Allen O'Reilly

Harbor Master

Whit Davies

Captain Finn

James Swendsen

Sgt. Sullivan

Lee Buechele

Caretaker

Brandon Wood

Ben (teenager)

Brianna Ferris

Sandy Jeffers

Andrew Bellamy

Aaron Skeen

Brody Wellmaker

James Anderson

Kevin Harrison

Carlos Hess

Christina Reynolds

Det. Sgt. Sharon Moore

Lake Roberts

MD Det. Hendley

Jennifer Baskette-Ridings

Angelia Jeffers

David Turner

Sleazy Bank Customer

Suehyla El-Attar Young

Sandy's Neighbor

Angela Ray

Librarian

Marilyn Chung

Student

Kalyn Wood

Cassie Jo Stoddart

Matt Hendren

Matthew Young

Cory Chapman

Tory Adamcik

Tyler Webster

Brian Draper

Andrew Sweeney

Det. John Ganske

Parisa Johnston

Officer Bozek

Denise Arribas

Anna Stoddart

Kirsten Benson

Matt's Mom

Suzanne Salhaney

Aunt Allison

Kristina Arjona

Cousin Kelsey

Briana Starks

Ticket Taker

Kevin Todde Coughlin

Delivery Guy (uncredited)

Todd Brown

Tommy Ray

Bill Osinski

Self - True Crime Author / Former Journalist

Denise Lang

Self - Author, 'The Dark Son'

John Johnston

Self - Former Reporter, A Current Affair

Frank McAdams

Self - True Crime Author, 'Final Affair'

Katherine Ramsland

Self - Forensic Psychologist

Caleb J. Spivak

Harvey Robinson

Fidelus Singleton

Clarence Purdie

Hannah Alline

Sarah Harris

Eileen Bridgeman Biernat

Self - True Crime Author, 'Stalking Mary'