Garcia's Secret Girlfriend

Thomas Lennon

Lieutenant Jim Dangle

Cedric Yarbrough

Deputy Sven Jones

Kerri Kenney

Deputy Trudy Wiegel

Carlos Alazraqui

Deputy James Oswaldo Garcia

Wendi McLendon-Covey

Deputy Clementine Johnson

Robert Ben Garant

Deputy Travis Junior

Niecy Nash-Betts

Deputy Raineesha Williams

Mary Birdsong

Deputy Cherisha Kimball

Lisa LoCicero

Maria Storm

Katie Lohmann

Bachelorette #2

Nick Swardson

Terry Bernadino

Zach Galifianakis

Frisbee

Kyle Dunnigan

Craig Pullin

Jill-Michele Meleán

Maria Garcia

Jayme Rhae Edwards

Mrs. Frisbee

George Sharperson

Officer Moore

Corinne Chooey

Bachelorette #1

Dustin Lancaster

Juan