Presumed Innocent

Jake Gyllenhaal

Rozat 'Rusty' Sabich

Ruth Negga

Barbara Sabich

Bill Camp

Raymond Horgan

O-T Fagbenle

Nico Della Guardia

Chase Infiniti

Jaden Sabich

Elizabeth Marvel

Lorraine Horgan

Nana Mensah

Det. Alana 'Rigo' Rodriguez

Renate Reinsve

Carolyn Polhemus

Peter Sarsgaard

Tommasino 'Tommy' Molto

Kingston Rumi Southwick

Kyle Sabich

Lily Rabe

Dr. Liz Rush

Tate Birchmore

Michael Caldwell

Matthew Alan

Dalton Caldwell

Virginia Kull

Eugenia

Noma Dumezweni

Judge Laryn Lyttle

Roberta Bassin

Mrs. Lancaster

Gabby Beans

Mya Winslow

James Hiroyuki Liao

Dr. Herbert Kumagai

Mark Harelik

Liam Reynolds / Liam Reynolds (archive footage) (uncredited)

Sarunas J. Jackson

Clifton

MARS

Jeanine

Marco Rodríguez

Brian Ratzer

Bryan Gallo

Reporter Jones

Bridget Oberlin

Reporter Lisa James

Eileen Álvarez

Laura Ratzer

Timothy Davis-Reed

Father Martin

Betsy Soo

Judge Smith

Bella Shaw

Reporter

Grace Rowe

Detective Stevens

Rosanna Arquette

Kate

Yomary Cruz

Reporter #1

Christopher Wolfe

Reporter #2

Alexandra Fatovich

Reporter #3

Cinai Leonard

Tina

Christopher Thornton

Jeremy Buck

Brian Cousins

Dr. Harris

Rick Chambers

Anchor

Rasha Goel

Legal Expert

Marcus Parks

Radio Host 1 (voice)

Ed Larson

Radio Host 2 (voice)

Henry Zebrowski

Radio Host 3 (voice)

Brit Prawat

Podcast Host 2 (voice)

Ashley Flowers

Podcast Host 1 (voice)

Mary Lynn Rajskub

Pathologist

Mladen Radojicic

Judge Lyttle's Bailiff