You Wish

John Ales

Genie

Harley Jane Kozak

Gillian Apple

Alex McKenna

Mickey Apple

Nathan Lawrence

Travis Apple

Jerry Van Dyke

Max

John Rhys-Davies

Mustafa

Melissa Joan Hart

Sabrina Spellman

Nick Bakay

Salem Saberhagen (voice)

Dan Lauria

Coach

Sam Gifaldi

Little Coach

Ted Henning

Big Travis

Mathea Webb

Victoria

Vanessa Evigan

Jill

Ralph P. Martin

Satyr Messenger

Clint Carmichael

Cop #1

Luigi Amodeo

Don Juan

Wendie Jo Sperber

Margo

Willie Garson

Herbie

Jessica Walter

Estelle

Mark DeCarlo

Cable Repairman

Andrew Masset

Dracula

Larry Cedar

Mummy

Spencer Vrooman

Matt

Sylvain Cecile

Frankenstein

Kente Scott

Kid

Aaron Michael Metchik

Mitch

Ben Foster

Earl

Mike Randleman

Mr. Schlessinger

Mark Voland

Vampire

Taylor Negron

Jovelhexasplix

Stephen Sustarsic

Clerk

James M. Connor

Genie Emcee

Michael Emanuel

Harassed Genie

Jerimav Shubba Erby

Football Player

Dale E. Turner

Genie #1

Marguerite MacIntyre

Jessica

Franc Ross

Pirate Captain

John LaMotta

Toothless Pirate

Jay Edward Anthony

Pirate in Silly Clothes

Kirsten Storms

Betsy

Tommy Madden

Alien

Erik von Detten

Jeff

Karen Lynn Scott

Malevola

George Furth

Minister

Phil Leeds

Old Man

Kenneth Mars

Santa Clause