Sarah Michelle Gellar

Sarah Michelle Gellar / Self

Gina Vendetti (voice)

Kristin Ramsey

Debbie

Buffy Summers

Seventh Sister (Voice)

Jenny (voice) / Phyllis (voice)

Buffy Summers

Self - Guest Judge

Self - Host

Mercenary 2 (voice) / Teela (voice)

Bridget Kelly / Siobhan Martin

Self

Betty Crocker (voice) / Big Bad Wolf's Wife (voice) / Cashier (voice) / Doug's Girlfriend (voice) / Holly McClane (voice) / Lioness (voice) / Muffin's Owner (voice) / Peppa-Mint (voice) / Sarah Connor (voice) / Soccer Player (voice) / Vanessa Alston (voice) / Woman (voice)

Marie (voice)

Self

Sydney Roberts

Self

Self - Guest

Self - Guest

Gwen Stephanie

That Actress on That Show (voice)

Andromeda (voice)

Self

Sarah Michelle Gellar

Self

Kendall Hart Lang

Self

Cici Cooper

The Headmistress

Kathryn Merteuil

Helen Shivers

Daphne Blake

Daphne Blake

Karen Davis

Gwendy Doll (voice)

Krysta Kapowski / Krysta Now

Sorrow

Auditioner

April O'Neil (voice)

Amanda Shelton

Brett Eisenberg

Karen Davis

Veronika

Ella (voice)

Joanna Mills

Cindy Bandolini

Self

Karen (archive footage)

Nicole (voice)

Jane Robinson

Self

Jessica

Herself