Schmigadoon!

Keegan-Michael Key

Josh Skinner

Cecily Strong

Melissa Gimble

Dove Cameron

Betsy McDonough / Jenny Banks

Kristin Chenoweth

Mildred Layton / Miss Codwell

Alan Cumming

Dooley Blight / Mayor Aloysius Menlove

Aaron Tveit

Danny Bailey / Topher

Fred Armisen

Reverend Howard Layton

Jaime Camil

Doc Jorge Lopez

Ariana DeBose

Emma Tate

Ann Harada

Florence Menlove

Tituss Burgess

Narrator

Daniel Bernardo

Core Dancer

Amanda Cleghorn

Core Dancer

Serena Crouse

Cabaret Girl Annie / Core Dancer

Julia Harnett

Core Dancer

Ericka Hunter

Cabaret Girl Molly / Core Dancer

Gray Monczka

Core Dancer

Ashley Brooke St. John

Core Dancer

Julio Fuentes

Core Dancer

Marina Lazzaretto

Cabaret Girl / Core Dancer

Derek Piquette

Core Dancer

Warren Yang

Core Dancer

Amitai Marmorstein

Pete the Milkman / Skeet the Hot Dog Man / Skeet the Juror

Katrina Reynolds

Backup Singer / Core Dancer / Court Observer

Alex Gullason

Alex / Young Woman #1

Liam Quiring-Nkindi

Carson

Jessica Keeling

Core Dancer

Caitriona Murphy

Core Dancer / Court Observer

Karin Konoval

Female Barfly / Female Barfly (voice)

Kevin McNulty

Farmer McDonough / Father Flanagan

Bijou Brattston

Orphan Dancer / Tootie McDonough

Darcey Johnson

Innkeeper Harvey / Reporter

Scott Patey

Larry the Fireman / Reporter

Sarah Formosa

Core Dancer

Shelley Stewart Hunt

Core Dancer

Jane Krakowski

Bobby Flanagan / Countess Gabriele Von Blerkom

Patrick Page

Octavius Kratt

Milana Wan

Orphan / Orphan Dancer

Kris Grzella

Core Dancer / Jail Dancer / Tribal Dancer

Marisa Gold

Marisa

Garfield Wilson

Henry the Iceman

Jak Barradell

Core Dancer

Tristan Chad Ghostkeeper

Core Dancer

Jared Khalifa

Core Dancer

Troy Mclaughlin

Core Dancer

Matt Nethersole

Core Dancer

Sam Strasfeld

Core Dancer

Isabel Birch

Little Orphan

Bianca Melchior

Core Dancer / Kelly, Audition Dancer / Tribal Dancer

Shane Simpson

Core Dancer / Jail Dancer / Tribal Dancer

Kairo Ellis

Orphan

Martin Short

Oscar the Leprechaun / Steve the Leprechaun

Kyra Leroux

Carrie

Astrid Trueman

Nellie

Pedro Salvín

Old Doc Lopez

Sarah Hayward

Helen

Michelle Rios

Mrs. Lopez

Justine Gera

Cabaret Girl Elsie Vale / Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer

Andrew Kyrzyk

Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer

Alex Wong

Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer

Sharona D'Ornellas

Cabaret Girl Pepper / Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer

Katherine Gayle

Cabaret Girl / Core Dancer / Tribal Dancer

Josh St. John

Core Dancer

Arielle Tuliao

Barfly Singer / Woman #3

Viola Abley

Freckle-Faced Girl

Nolen Dubuc

Buck-Toothed Boy

Ridley Havok McLeod

Wild Hair Boy

Peyton Amelia Feltham

Choir / Tap Dancer

Anthony Juo

Choir / Tap Dancer

Ema Lake

Choir / Tap Dancer

Jenna Lamb

Choir / Tap Dancer

Alisa Lymar

Choir / Tap Dancer

Leah Park

Choir / Tap Dancer

Matias Wong

Choir / Tap Dancer

Alex Barima

Freddy

Cassandra Consiglio

Nancy

Willow Rose Walker

Young Melissa

Ella Wejr

Dance Orphan #3 / Orphan Dancer

Peppermint

Madam Vina

Timothy Webber

Marv

David Adams

Corn Puddin' Cook

Jason Burkart

Buford Riggs

Stephanie Cho

Waitress

Thomas Wayne Hum

Husband Ted

Levi McCachen

Like Minded Guy

Iris Quinn

Joanna

Nikolai Witschl

Undertaker

Leana Yu

Birthing Woman Holly

Style Dayne

DJ

Whitney Lykins

Bridesmaid

Rryla McIntosh

Bride

Emma Pedersen

Young Woman #2

Inca Scott

Tap Dancer

Dolores Drake

Biddy #1

Eileen Barrett

Biddy #2

Immanuel Chibota

Newsie

Felice Kakaletris

Little Girl

Yvette Lu

Fertility Doctor

Jessica Vosk

Little Girl's Mother

Sandy Robson

Angry Dad

Patti Allan

Mrs. Silwinski

Joshua Harding

Josh's Patient

Lee Shan Gibson

Cop

Holly Arthur

Josh's Patient

Phillip Joseph Steward

Josh's Patient

Matt Afonso

Robber Prisoner

Justin Stone

Conrad Prisoner

Steeven K.

Jazz Musician

Micaela Nyland

Priscilla, Audition Dancer

Mark Logtenberg

Killer Prisoner

Michael Q. Adams

Advisor

David Beairsto

Advisor

Gerry South

Judge

Jennie Ford

Court Stenographer

Ellexis Wejr

Orphan Dancer

Alice Comer

Tiny Tap Dancer

Aletheia Berry

Orphan Dancer

Jacob Ian Dalzell

Orphan Dancer

Haven Gin

Orphan Dancer

Joy Lho

Orphan Dancer

Ayla McMillan

Orphan Dancer

Noah Park

Orphan Dancer

Lincoln Russo

Orphan Dancer

Anya-Shae Johnson

Orphan Dancer

Cole Sivertson

Orphan Dancer

Khamisa Wilsher

Barfly Singer

Tanya Jade

Barfly Singer

Jacqueline Robbins

Bernstein Sister

Joyce Robbins

Bernstein Sister

Felicia Simone

Backup Singer

Siera Staples

Backup Singer

Sarah Cantuba

New Narrator