Jenny Slate

Bianca

Piper Paisley (voice)

Mona-Lisa / Mona-Lisa Saperstein

Huntress Wizard (voice)

Huntress (voice)

Missy Foreman-Greenwald (voice)

Nancy O'Malley (voice)

Ruth (voice) / Tammy (voice) / Tammy (voice) / 8th Grade Girl (voice) / Tammy (voice) / Becca (voice) / Tammy (voice) / Bernadette (voice) / Tammy (voice) / Rosa (voice) / Tammy (voice) / Sally (voice) / Tammy (voice) / Wish Paper Person (voice) / Tammy's Bubbie / Tammy / Wish Paper Person / Tammy's Bubbie (voice)

Pony Head (voice)

Self - Various Characters

Self

Judy Tobin (voice)

Pipi / Cookie Mama Cashier / Beatrice (voice)

Self

Amelia Gordon

Self

Herself - Narrator / Herself - Storyteller

Self

Self - Guest

Jaclyn (voice)

Self - Guest

Karen Grisham

Jane (voice)

Self

Jess

Miss Nanny (voice)

Self

Valerie Da Vinci (voice)

Dr. Dora Skirth

Big Nose

Assistant Mayor Dawn Bellwether (voice)

Gidget (voice)

Bonnie Stevenson

Zoe

Harley Quinn (voice)

Gidget (voice)

Marcel (voice)

Mrs. Wiggins (voice)

Allysa

Margo

Emily

Gidget (voice)

Vanessa

Emma Moore

Officer Morgan Daniels

Tammy (voice)

Marcel (voice)

Stacy

Jocelyn

Donna

Marla Lewan

Yoga Couple

Mitzy (voice)

Herself

Nani (voice)

Dana Jacobs

Rose

Emily Milburton

Jodi

Gidget (voice)

Frances