Why Me?

James Franco

Vincent Martino / Frankie Martino

Maggie Gyllenhaal

Eileen 'Candy' Merrell

Chris Bauer

Bobby Dwyer

Chris Coy

Paul Hendrickson

Lawrence Gilliard Jr.

Chris Alston

Margarita Levieva

Abigail 'Abby' Parker

Emily Meade

Lori Madison

Natalie Paul

Sandra Washington

Michael Rispoli

Rudy Pipilo

Kayla Foster

Barbara

Daniel Sauli

Tommy Longo

David Krumholtz

Harvey Wasserman

Dominique Fishback

Donna 'Darlene' Pickett

Gbenga Akinnagbe

Larry Brown

Gary Carr

C.C.

Method Man

Rodney

Don Harvey

Danny Flanagan

Jamie Neumann

Dorothy 'Ashley' Spina

Matthias Sebastiun Garry

Pedestrian (uncredited)

Jacqueline Honulik

Claudette

Matthew James Ballinger

Gentle Ritchie

Shaun O'Hagan

Lieutenant Gerald Sweeney

Tamzin Brown

Terese

Tariq Trotter

Reggie Love

Finn Robbins

Adam

Michael Wren Gucciardo

Officer Jeanty

Brian McCarthy

Greg

David Aaron Baker

James Schuster

Garry Pastore

Matty 'The Horse'

Franca Vercelloni

Lynda

Thomas Glen Baker

Mitch

Cameron Cowperthwaite

Peter

Michael Kostroff

Rizzi

Brian Muller

Officer Grossman

Saul Stein

Marty Hodas

Gino Vento

Carlos

Carolyn Mignini

Joan

E.J. Carroll

Fat Mooney

James Ciccone

Carmine Patriccia

Genevieve Hudson-Price

Jocelyn

Ralph Macchio

Officer Haddix

Anwan Glover

Leon

Hannah Townsend

Elise

Thaddeus Street

Black Frankie

Andrea-Rachel Parker

Bernice

Kim Director

Shay