The Premise

B.J. Novak

Self - Host

Ben Platt

Ethan Streiber

Ayo Edebiri

Eve Stone

Tracee Ellis Ross

Rayna Bradshaw

Jermaine Fowler

Darren Williams

Melissa Saint-Amand

Vanessa Delacroix

Jon Bernthal

Chase Milbrandt

Boyd Holbrook

Aaron

Beau Bridges

William

Amy Landecker

Trish

Lucas Hedges

Jesse Wheeler

Kaitlyn Dever

Abbi Miller

O'Shea Jackson Jr.

Cooper

Ed Asner

Mr. Holmes

Brendan Scannell

Caleb Rose

Grace Song

Susie Xu

Lola Kirke

Allegra

Soko

Beth

Sylvia Grace Crim

Woman in the Bathroom

Benjamin Clément

Therapist

Daniel Dae Kim

Daniel Jung

Eric Lange

Eli Spector

Bryan Batt

Charles

George Wallace

Principal Wallace

Talia Balsam

Prosecutor

Martin Covert

Judge

Randal Gonzalez

Jury Foreman

Scott Takeda

Doctor Hopkins

Meagan Noel

Ex-Girlfriend 2

Taylor Shurte

Ex-Girlfriend 1

Cat Wilkinson

Ex-Girlfriend 3

Megan Rosen

Emily

Jeff DeRouen

Online Therapist

Patrick Kirton

Ethan's Dad

Andy Dylan

Arresting Officer

Desus Nice

Daniel 'Desus Nice' Baker

The Kid Mero

Joel 'The Kid Mero' Martinez

Michael Barbaro

Michael Barbaro

Emily Nelson

Keri Piña

Michelle Jubilee Gonzalez

NGL Security Guard

Matthew Osborne

NGL Co-Worker #1

Denni Barrett

Balloon Pilot

Jenny Tran

Jenny

Erin Flannery

NGL Employee

David Douglas

Mr. Decherd

Kyle Langdon-Weyrich

Student

David Paladino

Hugh Clark

Geran Simpson

NGL Co-Worker #2

Rose Bianca Grue

Juror

Bridget Malbrough

Juror

Ronnie Yelverton

Reporter

Andrew Penrow

Civil Rights Attorney

Julia Goldani Telles

Kailey

Devin Sidell

Assistant Principal

Megan Truong

Kelly Kim

Lily Liu

Susie's Mom

Emeily Flyr

Alyssa

Michael Graziadei

Pastor Jack

Jia Tolentino

Commenter (voice)

Jordan Mann

Naomi

Carrie Bernans

Naomi

Tirol Palmer

Sarah

Jeff Grays

Security Guard

Monica R. Harris

Meredith

Jariah Johnson

Student

Scott Green

Paunchy Office Worker

Kasia Trepagnier

Student

Laura Cayouette

Susie

Pierce Kang

Young Daniel

Corin Scialabba

Young Eli

Cindy L. Jefferson

Gail

Joanna Daniel

Alice

Jonas Chartock

Troy

Freedom Bridgewater

Marcus

Lorrie Chilcoat

Sandra

Jason Bayle

Focus Grouper

Nadiya Khan

Alexa

Dan Savage

Dan Savage

Asa Akira

Asa Akira

Jayden Hamilton

Bully Girl

Max Gabriel Morgan

Bully

Andy Cohen

Andy Cohen