The Good Cop

Josh Groban

Tony Caruso Jr.

Tony Danza

Tony Caruso Sr.

Monica Barbaro

Cora Vasquez

Isiah Whitlock Jr.

Burl Loomis

Bill Kottkamp

Ryan Domki

Brooke Carrell

Detective

John Scurti

Wendell Kirk

Victor Cruz

Sergeant Rudner

Matthew Saldivar

Gordy

Glenn Fitzgerald

Father Kokesh

Frank Whaley

Joseph Privett

Alice Spivak

Mrs. Spiro

Molly Price

Captain

Ann Mahoney

Phillis / Phyllis

Adam DeCarlo

CSI Tech

Stacey Raymond

Another Uniform Cop

Rebecca Rittenhouse

Macy Clark

Connor Tillman

Deputy Tillman

Emma Ishta

Belinda Mannix

Christopher James Baker

Corey Speck

Teddy Coluca

Al Monte

Andrew Dolan

Lionel Sykes

Alanna Ubach

Debbi Paddock

Joe Holt

Agent Conway

Aaron Serotsky

Agent Hodges

Chaka DeSilva

Remy DeRosa

Bob Saget

Richie Knight

Andy Grotelueschen

Dr. Alvin Roundie

Billy Malone

Sergeant Chet Finch

Orfeh

Donna Livingston

John Carroll Lynch

Sherman Smalls

David Furr

Mickey

Margo Seibert

Lois Ronstadt

C. Thomas Howell

Businessman

Joy Suprano

Jocelyn

Brooke Langton

Joy

Edward Carnevale

Dorfirio Santini

Dan Byrd

Donovan Demark

Caroline Aaron

Olivia Nyborg

Alyssa Cheatham

Young girl

Lynn Marocola

NYPD (uncredited)

Alexander Flores

Stork

Alex Webb

Inspector Quinn

Mattea Conforti

Young Niece

Sedly Bloomfield

Landlord

Agnes Chung

News Reporter

Max Daniels

Jack Livingston

Diane Findlay

Friendly Aunt

Ron Scott

Police Union Rep

Scott Aiello

Sgt. Aiello

Greg Crowe

Barbershop Customer

Stan Demidoff

Sgt. Stanley

Ambrose Martos

Curious Hal

Dave Mizzoni

Second Fan

Jun Naito

Forensic Investigator

Ariel Padilla

Big Fan

Ellen Ratner

Mrs. Zucker

Gurdeep Singh

Mr. Patel

Steven Solis

Frankie Storch

Justin Ahdoot

College Student

Jason Michael Evans

Masked CSI Officer

Gina Ferrall

Quinlan's Secretary

Fred Inkley

Sgt. Wickes

Jamil A.C. Mangan

State Trooper

Christopher Mann

Prison Warden

Alex Orthwein

Guy at Ringside

Hannah D. Scott

Brooke Smalls

Hannah Tinker

Helen Quinlan

Allan R. Walker

Referee

Andre B. Blake

Dr. Kornbluth

Steve Cirbus

Nolan Zander

Reade Kelly

Joey Wingate

Eden Malyn

Cynthia

Harry Sutton Jr.

Dale Coruthers

O'Neil Thomas

Shoe Rental Guy

Bill Timoney

Alley Manager

Cory Candrilli

Coranet Reality Bowler

Melissa O'Donnell

Joey's Niece

Jose Guns Alves

Enforcer

Carly Brooke

Jolene

Chris Doi

First Paramedic

Gavin Haag

FBI Special Agent #2

Jo D. Jonz

FBI Special Agent #1

Thomas Kopache

Mr. Entwhistle

Larissa Laurel

Second Paramedic

Geraldine Leer

DeRosa's Lawyer

Michael Nostrand

Laundromat Manager

Marcos Palma

Roach

Shaun Rey

Enrico Kraus

Leila Sbitani

Local Reporter

Anthony Vincent

Street Musician

Tony White

Bartender

Michael-Scott Druckenmiller

FDNY Paramedic

Hugo Salazar Jr.

Agent Rhinehart

Joseph Dellger

Studio Official

Alix Elias

Mrs. Prima

Jacqueline Guillen

First Volunteer

Mary Neely

Backstage PA

Terrence Shingler

Studio Guard

Kensington Tallman

Amateur Magician

Tam Young

Second Volunteer

Quentin

Loud audience member

Kate Grimes

Karen Trumbo

Andy Taylor

Sheriff Gaddy

Brennan Taylor

Andre Rifkin

Bryan Burton

Frank Malton the Desk Clerk

Donald Flores

Maintenance Worker

Aaron David Kapner

Friendly Cop

Maximillian McNamara

Daryl Teasdale

Dean Neistat

Skier

Angel Pai

Attractive Woman

Claire Saunders

Macy's Desk Clerk

Pablo Thomas

Ski Instructor

Ashlyn Alessi

Lodge Staff

Domenico Del Giacco

Harry

Josh Segarra

Warren

Stephanie Kurtzuba

Evelyn

Clyde Baldo

Stax

Jeffrey Bean

City Clerk

John Goodlow

Officiant

Christopher Joseph Gray

Patrol Officer

Charmar Jeter

Bar Patron

Ricardo Cortés

Young Busboy

Leila Grace

Adorable Girl

Tristan Griffin

Uniform Cop

Carlos Ibarra

Porfirio Santini (Busboy)

Marty Krzywonos

Frankie the Risotto Lover

Todd Lewis

First Financier

Mike Massimino

Johnny

Ava Lee Scott

Woman with Necklace

Jacqueline Springfield

Nurse

Kazy Tauginas

First Gangster

Damir Mrkulic

N.Y.P.D / Swat

David Negri

Paulie's Friend

Thaddeus Daniels

Henry the Doorman

Bonnie Flannery

Neighbor in Window

Wai Ching Ho

Dr. Kim

Lane Napper

Uniform Cop

Barbara Singer

Mrs. Ackroyd

Carol To

Vera

Danielle Farrier

Donovan's Mother