Episode One

Evan Peters

Jeffrey Dahmer

Richard Jenkins

Lionel Dahmer

Molly Ringwald

Shari Dahmer

Michael Learned

Catherine Dahmer

Niecy Nash-Betts

Glenda Cleveland

Karen Malina White

Shirley Hughes

Rodney Burford

Tony Hughes

Penelope Ann Miller

Joyce Dahmer

Khetphet Phagnasay

Southone Sinthasomphone

Phet Mahathongdy

Somdy Sinthasomphone

Brayden Maniago

Somsack Sinthasomphone

Scotty Paophavihanh

Anouke Sinthasomphone

Somlit Inthalangsy

Sayamone Sinthasomphone

Dyllón Burnside

Ronald Flowers

Nikea Gamby-Turner

Mildred Lindsey

David Barrera

Chief Arreola

Matthew Alan

Officer Gabrish

DaShawn Barnes

Rita Isbell

Scott Michael Morgan

Officer Balcerzak

Kieran Tamondong

Konerak Sinthasomphone

Dia Nash

Sandra Smith

Nick Fisher

Young Jeffrey Dahmer

Josh Braaten

Young Lionel Dahmer

Nigel Gibbs

Jesse Jackson

Savannah Brown

Young Joyce Dahmer

Cameron Cowperthwaite

Steven Hicks

Ken Clement

Wally The Butcher

Maurice Demus

Jacob

Furly Mac

Christopher Scarver

Jake Green

Officer Kelly

Amy Mack

Barbara Hughes

Rodney J. Hobbs

African American Sergeant

Clark Moore

Deputy Chief

Keyla McNeely

Dorothy Straughter

Raymond Watanga

Sopa Princewill

Corey Timmons

Will Hughes

Kyrsten V. Williams

Kim Hughes

Alex Hyde-White

Doctor

Emma Kennedy

Denise

Patrick Day

Chaplain Berkum

Benjahmin Svyatoslavich

Anthony Sears

Jackson Hurst

Stone

Michael Beach

Det. Dennis Murphy

Colby French

Patrick Kennedy

Mac Brandt

Robert Rauth

Shaun Brown

Tracy Edwards

Grant Harvey

Rolf Mueller

Ato Blankson-Wood

Aaron

Chris Gann

Police Officer #1

Rhoyle Ivy King

Don

Joshua Edward Moore

CSI Investigator

Mark Reininga

Young Police Officer

Leanne Suter

On Camera Reporter